Investigators say Andrews planned for weeks to kill Peace to get his hands on about $6,000 in savings and her 1995 Nissan pickup. According to the younger Byrd, he was supposed to strangle Peace but balked at the last minute so Andrews did it instead. The two put Peace’s body in the bathtub and went out for pizza.

They eventually picked up Garrell Boyd who helped them take Peace’s body to Crow Creek Road and set it on fire